Cowboy Bebop, Vol. 1

September 2, 2023 — Yutaka Nanten

Table of Contents

Review

It is no easy thing to take what is perhaps the greatest anime of all time and extent or add to that story in a medium that loses so much of what makes the anime incredible. You don’t have the immensely talented voice-acting cast. The lively animation stills and the colors melt away. You lose perhaps the best score ever put to an anime from Yoko Kanno. This last loss is the most painful, as Cowboy Bebop is inseparable from its music - its concept is experimentation in jazz.

The manga is silent, black-and-white, and there’s no jazz in its formulation.

The art is fine. Something about the eyes baffles the mind. One would think you could freeze-frame the anime and look at the eyes, but the artists here opt for a much more generic manga eye style that looks really bizarre.

The stories are, for the most part, fine - they’re all about the crew being broke and going for bounties that inevitably flop somehow.

I eliminated a whole star for the one story inside that is essentially one long transphobic thing. I know anime and manga both have weird relationships with trans characters, but this was very poor, indeed.

Author: Yutaka Nanten

Last read: 2023-09-02

Rating: 2

Form: Fiction

Genre: Comic Book

Times read: 1

Copies owned: 1

Fun score: 2.00