Envisioning Information
October 3, 2023 — Edward R. Tufte
Table of Contents
Review
Another read for work. This is the third Tufte I’ve read and they certainly have diminishing returns. I found The Visual Display of Quantitative Information dated, but worthwhile in its approach to data. Then Beautiful Evidence to be more of a coffee table book repeating some strong opinions from Tufte that have not survived their aging.
This is more of the same. Tufte loves complexity - in several of these books he cites archaic handmade train schedules. These are prettier to look at than to use, and they’re not the prettiest things to look at to begin with. Tufte often talks about simplicity being essential, but then also repeats statements something like: “you can’t treat your audience as if they’re stupid, uncaring, or obtuse.” It feels like he makes those statements to get away with overly complex graphics.
He highlights a projection of the Rockefeller Center surroundings by Constantine Anderson as a great joy of visualizing information, noting that it goes so far as to depict individual windows. What is the point of identifying individual windows on a map? There really isn’t one. Tufte notes that Anderson spent 20 years on this map, and then it becomes clear that this is an art piece, not a utility.
I would be interested in seeing a modern version of these books, using modern examples and modern design language. These have been rather left in the past, and I can’t imagine anything but the first book being useful to the practicing data scientist or designer. I think Rastersysteme für die visuelle Gestaltung - Grid systems in Graphic Design is an excellent design reference for layout and much more practical, having read it over 10 years ago, anyway. Page 82 of the Tufte cites Die neue Typografie which I haven’t read, but the excerpt/graphic from that seems in the same design language as Muller’s work and so is probably the most practical thing I took away.