Heartland

This will be a short note. Ana Simo’s Heartland was my small press book club’s March pick, and wow! Unfortunately, I did not like it. I found it so grating to read that I couldn’t finish it, despite getting about 90 pages into its 200something pagecount. I felt the use of slurs so over the top that it smelled like an amateur novelist trying to scare the reader, to tell them, Hey, this is Serious Stuff. But it did not work for me, and only made me roll my eyes. ...

March 26, 2026 · Ana Simo · No rating

No Names

DNF around page 100. Very, very, much not for me I’m afraid. This was a runner-up for my book club, and I was really hoping it’d win. So, when I saw a copy in a bookstore while traveling, I picked it up and took it to a bar to read a bit. I’ve struggled with it for around 10 days since. This book centers on teenage or thereabouts characters, who share a deep love of music, and are often musicians themselves. This means there is a lot of talk about different songs, lyrics, etc. Unfortunately, I absolutely detest reading song lyrics. This is a me problem, I want to be clear. It happens often enough, and the sort of saccharine or overly emotional quality to the dialogue alongside doesn’t work for me. In many cases, I just could not believe the characters or the way in which they spoke, nothing felt true to me. ...

September 21, 2025 · Greg Hewett · 

The Understory

I tried and tried. I got 5 pages in and started begging for paragraphs. I got 20 pages in and decided maybe it wasn’t the right time, so I put it down and read a 700 page fantasy book. I read 20 more pages and could barely force myself to focus on it. I put it down at 50 intending to DNF it. I see every review mention that it picks up at page 60, so I go back. At page 70 I start skimming again, totally unable to keep my focus. I find it painfully boring. I skimmed the rest. This style does not work for me at all. ...

June 22, 2025 · Saneh Sangsuk · 

Silver Nitrate

Notes Author: Silvia Moreno-Garcia Last read: 2025-03-02 Rating: 0 Form: Fiction Genre: Horror Times read: 1 Copies owned: 0 Fun score: 0.00

March 2, 2025 · Silvia Moreno-Garcia · 

The Apple in the Dark

DNF. Giving myself credit anyway because I got halfway through and 200 pages felt like 400. Author: Clarice Lispector Last read: 2024-11-19 Rating: 0 Form: Fiction Genre: Literary Fiction Times read: 1 Copies owned: 0 Fun score: 0.00

November 19, 2024 · Clarice Lispector · 

Everything for Everyone

I technically “finished” this because I skimmed the rest, but I more or less gave up after the Staten Island chapter. And ‘gave up’ feels like it does me a disservice, because I should be framing it as, “died after a long struggle.” I wanted to put it down after the first chapter. I stuck with it as long as I could. I am preconfigured to dislike it. I find anarchist theory and ideas to be woefully stupid, and I don’t even know how to phrase that more respectfully. I simply do not think they are in line with reality. Not in a “you’re saying no before thinking about it,” way. Part of it is that I believe a State can be a force for good, maybe in the same way that anarchists think that the Stateless can be. I’m not sure. I know there are a lot more examples in history of the State being a force for good than an anarchist “State” being a force for anything (to be fair, more examples of a State as evil, too). Anyway, I find the whole thought really dumb and bizarre, not to mention a woeful waste of time when so much could be done to improve the real world. ...

September 26, 2024 · M.E. O'Brien · 

Walkaway

DNF. Maybe I shouldn’t count this as “read” but I got about 70 pages in, and I’ve read books shorter than 70 pages so, what the hell? It’s not for me. I lived through the internet lingo of 2009 once and I don’t need to do it again. It has a lot of “clever” quips but none are enjoyable for me. I also find it very preachy and it violates my “make your social commentary not be tweet shaped” rule. ...

June 17, 2024 · Cory Doctorow · 

Age of Cage

DNF. I got to page 97 out of 220 pages of content in this book, and the writer made me work to get there. This is a shallow recounting of Cage’s filmography. If you would like pages spelling out summaries of Cage’s films loosely connected by biographies of the various people directing, writing, and casting them, you may enjoy it. Very little of Cage’s personal life is covered. Very little of what informs Cage’s decisions is covered. The writer often suggests things very boldly with not much in the way of evidence — thankfully these are typically opinions, but it still feels odd. ...

October 25, 2023 · Keith Phipps · 

Flow

DNF. I really don’t like the way this is written. It reads like pop psychology with a heavy dose of all the worst kinds of academic-turned-public writing. It’s overlong, recycles the same points over and over again, and could be half its length. I think a lot of the vocab it uses is very hokey and mystical. I allowed interest in this book because of the research background of the author, but this is not for me. I plan to review the notes and read the academic literature instead of this. ...

September 13, 2023 · Mihály Csíkszentmihályi ·