Dune Messiah

Probably a little closer to a 3.75/5. While very different from DUNE, I found this enjoyable in a different way. This is much shorter, and more interior and cerebral. The cast of characters is a little different with some notable changes and absences, I found myself yearning for characters we don’t see. What would X have thought? Why is Y absent? New cultures/species/organizations/what have you are present and these are interesting, though feel a bit shallower than those in the first book. I will say again that I think Denis made a wise decision to leave out all the CHOAM stuff in his adaptations - it was so boring in the first book that even Frank seems to have abandoned it. ...

March 24, 2024 · Frank Herbert · 

Dune

My friend Laleh’s review (https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4955092306) starts: “I’m not quite sure why I expected to dislike one of the most popular science fiction books of all time, but I did.” I felt the same, going in. When Denis’s DUNE came out a few years back, people raved. I kept hearing, “you’ve just GOT to see it on a big screen!” Sometimes when things are universally loved and praised, and I’m told how perfect they are, I have a spiteful urge to abstain. I didn’t go see the movie. Eventually, when I watched it on my TV at home, nothing really stood out to me. The second movie did get to me and I really enjoyed it. ...

March 19, 2024 · Frank Herbert ·